Sports Medicine Research: In the Lab & In the Field: The Acute Effects of Different Stretching Exercises on Jump Performance (Sports Med Res)
Thursday, November 10, 2011

The Acute Effects of Different Stretching Exercises on Jump Performance

The Acute Effects of Different Stretching Exercises on Jump Performance

Pacheco L, Balius R, Aliste L, Pujol M, and Pedret C. J Strength Cond Res. 2011 July; 25(11) 2991-2998.

Proper stretching prior to an activity is critical in avoiding injury. There are many different stretching exercises which can be performed and choosing the correct stretching exercise can actually enhance how the muscle and tendon will react to the demands placed on it during the activity. In order to better understand the effects of different stretching exercises with respect to jump performance, Pacheco and colleagues performed a double-blind, crossover study. The purpose of this study was “to evaluate the differences between different types of static stretching, which differ in terms of both their extension times and muscle activation or relaxation during the execution.” A total of 38 patients took part in the study in which 5 different stretching techniques were assigned. Patients performed 1 of the following lower extremity stretching interventions; 1) static passive stretching (stretch and hold for 30 seconds), 2) proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation (PNF) stretching (contracting for 4 seconds and passively stretched immediately after), 3) static active stretching in passive tension (contracting the antagonist muscle), 4) static active stretching in active tension (simultaneous contracting agonist muscle and stretching), or 5) no stretching. The effectiveness was evaluated by having the patients perform a jump test both before and after intervention. The jump test consisted of a squat jump, countermovement jump, and a drop jump. Each jump was performed 3 times with a 20 second rest between each jump and a 1 minute rest between each jump type. The best height for each of the three jumps was used. They found the static passive stretching, PNF stretching, and static active stretching in active tension showed significant increases in performance post intervention compared to the pre-test. The greatest significant difference was found in static active stretching in active tension.

There have been several recent SMR posts on the significance of static stretching (see below).  You can view them below in the related posts section.  This study was designed to examine the effect of performance on several different types of static stretching.  Overall this was an interesting study but some aspects were difficult to follow due to a lack details about the stretches being performed. However, the greatest statistical differences were detected in stretches which not only lengthened the muscle but also called on the muscle to contract in an elongated state replicating the demands of activates. This contracting action begs the question. “Are these stretches truly static stretches?” While all stretches were preformed differently, in essence all stretches in this study require some movement or contraction to increase flexibility and explosiveness as demanded by the activity. These PNF stretches may be more effective at increasing flexibility but also increasing the action potential of the muscles which can improve functional performance.  As reported in other posts, training the muscle towards its specific demands seems to yield the greatest effectives during activity. Many of you have offered up thoughts concerning the effects of injury prevention, but what about other gains? Have you seen or heard of your athletes making gains in elements of their activity such as jumping ability or explosiveness?

Written by: Kyle Harris
Reviewed by: Stephen Thomas

Related Posts:



Pacheco L, Balius R, Aliste L, Pujol M, & Pedret C (2011). The acute effects of different stretching exercises on jump performance. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 25 (11), 2991-8 PMID: 21993032

4 comments:

Shandi Lyn said...

It makes sense to me that stretching with active tension can improve jump performance. I haven't used too much static active stretching with active tension very often in the clinic, but with explosive jumping sports I feel that this information comes in handy. This form of stretching is one that I will probably implement a little more as passive stretching takes a lot more of my time that I don't have when getting a team ready for practice by myself. It is a technique that I feel coaches would be more inclined to use by seeing that it helps improve jump performance.

Kyle said...

Shandi,

Thanks for the post. I'm with you. With athletes who have class, work, and practice, I believe coaches and clinicians are feeling the pinch as well. Perhaps this is a well for us as clinicans to entice coaches to try and adopt. I also agree that once coaches and other clinicans see what an impact this can have on jump performance, we will be it used much more.

Abby Mettler said...

I can certainly see where increased flexibility through stretching could increase performance. Working with track and field athletes, particular events like the hurdles or steeplechase require a certain amount of flexibility for success. Athletes who have lost flexibility due to lack of training or when returning from injury often display a decrease in performance until their flexibility returns despite normal function in all other areas.

Kyle Harris said...

Abby,

I think you make a great point. Many times when we are dealing with injured athletes we also must deal, not only with increasing flexibility again, but perfrom this in a shortened time period. I think you post really hammers the point home that not only should we be familiar with techniques to increase flexibility, but also prepared to have exercises which can acomplish this goal in the necessary period of time. Thanks!

Post a Comment

When you submit a comment please click 'Subscribe by Email" (just below the comments) or "Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)" (at the bottom of this page) if you would like to receive a notification when another comment has been submitted to this post.

Please note that if you are using Safari and have problems submitting comments you may need to go to your preferences (privacy tab) and stop blocking third party cookies. Sorry for any inconvenience this may pose.