Sports Medicine Research: In the Lab & In the Field: Adolescent Amenorrheic Athletes Have Decreased Bone Health (Sports Med Res)
Monday, September 12, 2011

Adolescent Amenorrheic Athletes Have Decreased Bone Health

Bone Microarchitecture Is Impaired in Adolescent Amenorrheic Athletes Compared with Eumenorrheic Athletes and Nonathletic Controls

Ackerman KE, Nazem T, Chapko D, Russell M, Mendes N, Taylor AP, Bouxsein ML, Misra M. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2011 Aug 3. [Epub ahead of print]

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21816790


Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) is the most common modality used in the assessment of bone health. Some studies have suggested that quantitative assessment of bone microarchitecture may be a more sensitive measure of fracture risk. Adolescence and young adulthood are critical time periods for developing peak bone mass. In this study, the authors hypothesized that bone microarchitecture is impaired in adolescent and young adult amenorrheic athletes (absence of menses for at least 3 months in 6 month period, or absence of menarche at age 16) compared to eumenorrheic athletes (having at least 9 menses in past year) and non-athletic controls.
All three groups had bone mineral density (BMD) assessed by DEXA at the spine and hip. Bone microarchitecture was assessed by high-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography (HRpQCT) at the ultradistal radius (non-weight bearing bone) and the tibia (weight-bearing bone). As expected, BMD Z-scores of the lumbar spine were lower in amenorrheic athletes in comparison to the other two groups, and femoral neck and hip BMD Z-scores were the highest in eumenorrheic athletes. As far as bone microarchitecture assessed by HRpQCT, amenorrheic athletes had lower total density of the tibia and radius, as well as lower cortical density in the tibia, and lower trabecular density in the radius. The authors report that athletic activity is associated with greater total trabecular area and cortical perimeter at the weight-bearing tibia. Amenorrhea is associated with lower trabecular bone density of the non-weight bearing radius, lower total density and trabecular number, and greater trabecular separation at the tibia.

The concern for these young women is that if they develop abnormal bone health now, not only are they at an immediate higher fracture risk, they are at risk of impaired bone health later in life. The authors cite several studies that suggest that abnormal bone microarchitecture may be possible when DEXA is normal and that microarchitecture may be a more sensitive measure for fracture risk. They conclude in their article that independent of bone mineral density, microarchitecture provides information about bone parameters in the amenorrheic athlete. Although more data is obtained from the HRpQCT study compared to DEXA, it’s not clear when it would be appropriate and/or helpful to order the HRpQCT in the clinical setting. Future studies could compare the HRpQCT and DEXA data in individual patients to see how often abnormal bone microarchitecture is found in patients with a normal DEXA scan. A cost-benefit analysis could then be performed to determine if the increased sensitivity is worth the increased radiation exposure and higher cost. Clinically, these results are interesting because we often have a difficult time counseling our amenorrheic athletes regarding the dangers of amennorhea. Laboratory data and DEXA results are often normal in this patient population. Data from HRpQCT could provide objective data regarding distortion of bone architecture and information that may help female athletes with amenorrhea realize the possible risks they are taking with their bodies now and for the future. What is your experience with amenorrheic athletes and bone injury? Is this more difficult to deal with if you are male? What strategies do you use?

Written by: Kris Fayock, MD and Marc Harwood, MD
Reviewed by: Stephen Thomas

5 comments:

Whitney M said...

Realizing and knowing whether an athlete is amenorrheic is the first obstacle. During adolescence, talking about the status of your period is awkward and not something that is willingly brought up with your coach, especially a male coach. As a former athlete and current cross-country coach, I can say that amenorrhea and bone health is not something that was/is discussed with athletes.
I coach high school cross-country and at the beginning of each season, the athletic director and athletic trainer holds a parent meeting where rules and regulations are discussed. This season, the risk of concussions and the new preseason concussion tests were discussed. This might be one way of informing the parents of female athletes about the harmful affects of amenorrhea. It might be easier for girls to talk to their parents about health related topics.

Jeffrey B. Driban, PhD, ATC, CSCS said...

Hi Whitney:

That sounds like a great opportunity to raise the concerns of amenorrhea with the parents. It would a great opportunity to educate the parents about issues that can have long-term consequences. I think as a community we need to try and educate parents, coaches, and athletes more about some of these health issues that may have prolong consequences. I hope you are able to start that.

Kris Fayock said...

I agree, it's a great opportunity for patient education. In addition, hopefully these problems are discussed with their family physician or pediatrician. The pre-participation form includes questions on the athlete's menstrual period history and can be a good starting point for discussion of this.

Eunwook said...

I am working at high school as my clinical assignment for one year. I have a very rare case which is related to the adolescent athlete bone health issue. She is cross country runner (actually stopped running now) and has multiple stress fractures simultaneously on her left iliac crest, left 2nd metatarsal, and right tibia. She is Vitimin D deficiency and has a history of meningitis. She tested DEXA (Bone mineral density scan) scan and testing result was osteoporosis. I was surprised the fact that 16 years old girl has symptom of osteoporosis. What the potential factors this girl would have?

Kris Fayock said...

Sorry for the long delay in responding. The osteoporosis this athlete has is what we need to prevent at a much earlier stage. This is the complication from long standing amenorrhea as a part of the female athlete triad. Hopefully she continues to be closely monitored by her physician into looking at the cause of the vitamin d deficiency/osteoporosis, such as an eating disorder. Thanks for the post.

Post a Comment

When you submit a comment please click 'Subscribe by Email" (just below the comments) or "Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)" (at the bottom of this page) if you would like to receive a notification when another comment has been submitted to this post.

Please note that if you are using Safari and have problems submitting comments you may need to go to your preferences (privacy tab) and stop blocking third party cookies. Sorry for any inconvenience this may pose.